by Pinson, Alabama — The man accused of killing an Alabama high school cheerleader and shooting three others during a late-night bonfire gathering has been released from jail after posting bond, a decision that has sparked outrage and fear among the victim’s family.
Court records show Steven Tyler Whitehead was released Thursday from the Jefferson County Jail after a judge set his bond at $330,000. As a condition of his release, Whitehead is required to wear an electronic monitoring device while awaiting trial.
Deadly Bonfire Shooting Left One Teen Dead, Three Injured
The shooting occurred in October 2025 at a gathering in a remote wooded area locally referred to as “The Pit,” near Highway 75 North and Clay-Palmerdale Road.
Authorities say 18-year-old Kimber Mills, a senior at Cleveland High School, was fatally shot after Whitehead allegedly arrived at the party shortly after midnight and became involved in a heated confrontation.
According to investigators, the dispute escalated into violence when Whitehead allegedly pulled out a firearm and opened fire, striking Mills and three other people.
Victim Tried to Shield Friends During Gunfire
One of the survivors, 21-year-old Silas McCay, told reporters he was shot 10 times while attempting to protect others during the chaos.
“I look at her like a little sister to me,” McCay said from his hospital bed. “I tried everything I could. I wish there was more I could’ve done.”
McCay said the confrontation began after concerns were raised about Whitehead allegedly attempting to approach Mills, leading to a physical altercation moments before the gunfire erupted.
Teen Cheerleader Succumbs to Severe Injuries
Mills was transported to UAB Hospital in Birmingham after suffering gunshot wounds to the head and leg. Despite emergency treatment, doctors determined her injuries were not survivable.
Her sister, Ashley Mills, later announced her death following an emotional honor walk at the hospital attended by hundreds.
“Our sweet baby sister went to be with the Lord,” Ashley wrote in a social media post. “She was and is so loved by so many.”
The family ultimately honored Kimber’s wish to be an organ donor after placing her on a do-not-resuscitate order due to catastrophic brain trauma.
Remembered as a Bright Student With Big Plans
Friends and family described Mills as a vibrant and compassionate young woman. She was a cheerleader and track athlete and had plans to attend the University of Alabama in 2026 with dreams of becoming a nurse.
“She had a little spunk to her step,” her sister said.
Bond Decision Sparks Family’s Fear and Frustration
After learning of Whitehead’s release, Ashley Mills shared her reaction publicly, saying the decision has added to the family’s distress.
Read Also: Man Critically Injured After Being Shot in Chest, Collapses Outside Philadelphia Store
“Justice for Kimber — that’s all we want,” she wrote. “Knowing he’s out just brings more anxiety. I’ll stay home.”
The Jefferson County District Attorney’s Office declined to comment further on the bond ruling.
Whitehead remains charged with murder in Mills’ death and attempted murder for the three additional victims. The case is still pending.
Should bond decisions be reconsidered in violent crime cases like this? Share your thoughts, concerns, or reactions in the comments below.
